Don
Grace Cary via Getty Images
Passport photos are seldom flattering, often capturing us in less than ideal lighting and without the chance to flash our most cheerful smiles. If you’ve ever been instructed to maintain a neutral expression when getting your passport photo taken, you might wonder why smiling is so frowned upon for this official document. The answer is more nuanced than a simple “no smiling” rule, and it’s closely tied to technology and international security standards. Let’s delve into the specifics of smiling in passport photos and what is actually permissible.
The Neutral Expression Requirement: What the Rules Actually Say
It’s a common misconception that smiling is strictly forbidden in passport photos. In the United States, the State Department doesn’t explicitly ban smiling. Instead, their guidelines mandate a “neutral facial expression with both eyes open and mouth closed.” Applicants are required to look directly at the camera, facing forward. This might sound like a ban on smiling, but technically, it leaves a little room for interpretation.
According to a State Department spokesperson, “An applicant actually can smile in their passport photo, as long as both of their eyes are open and their mouth is closed in the photo.” So, a slight, closed-lip smile might be acceptable. However, showing your teeth is definitely not permissible, and this is where the concept of a “neutral expression” becomes crucial. Think less about avoiding happiness and more about maintaining a consistent, easily recognizable facial appearance. Perhaps the best approach is to aim for a relaxed, natural look, avoiding any exaggerated expressions.
Why No Smiling? The Role of Facial Recognition Technology
The primary reason behind the discouragement of smiling in passport photos is the increasing use of facial recognition software at airports and border control checkpoints worldwide. While humans can easily recognize faces with varying expressions, machines require a more standardized approach.
Karolina Turowska, a biometric photography and travel expert at Passport-Photo.Online, explains, “The main reason for banning smiling is the introduction of facial recognition software at airports and other border control checkpoints.” Many ports of entry now utilize automated systems to scan passports and photographs, relying on algorithms rather than solely on human officers.
“Algorithms don’t work as we do,” Turowska clarifies. “To compare a 3D face with a 2D passport photo, they need to pinpoint and measure the users’ facial features. It includes the distance between the pupils, ears, nose and mouth, the mouth’s and the eyes’ width, and many others. Smiling can make it harder, as it alters facial proportions.” A smile, especially a broad one with teeth showing, changes the shape of your mouth and cheeks, potentially distorting key facial measurements that the software relies upon for accurate identification.
Katy Nastro, a travel expert and spokesperson for Going, emphasizes this point: “Smiling wide with teeth makes it harder to verify eye color and general face shape by passport officials ― namely biometric technology ― who need to confirm your identity. With a majority of places using facial recognition technology at border controls, this is even more important as current biometric tech often has a hard time if points on the face are shifted.” Therefore, the neutral expression is not just about aesthetics; it’s about ensuring the effectiveness of biometric identification systems designed to enhance security and streamline travel.
Global Standards: It’s Not Just a US Rule
The principle of avoiding smiles in passport photos is not unique to the United States; it’s a globally recognized standard. “Avoiding smiling in passport photos is a universal rule for most countries,” notes Turowska. Although the specific interpretation of a “neutral facial expression” can vary slightly between countries due to different facial recognition technologies, the underlying principle remains consistent.
The International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) plays a key role in setting these global standards. As the State Department spokesperson mentioned, “The International Civil Aviation Organization ‘sets global standards and recommended practices for travel documents.’” These guidelines include recommendations for facial expressions in passport photos to ensure international interoperability and security.
While most countries adhere to the neutral expression rule, some may have stricter interpretations. For example, France has been known to have particularly stringent requirements, even disallowing subtle upturns at the corners of the mouth. This highlights that while a slight, closed-mouth smile might be technically acceptable in some regions, adopting a truly neutral expression is the safest approach to avoid any issues, regardless of your location.
Historical Context: How Passport Photo Rules Evolved
Passport photo rules haven’t always been as strict as they are today. Madison Blancaflor, a senior editor at The Points Guy, points out, “Passport photos weren’t always as strict as they are today. When passport photos first started to be used, there were very limited ― if any ― regulations to what the photos included. You can find some very interesting historical examples online of old passports with people playing instruments or wearing distracting hats. However, over the years more regulations have been put into place to heighten security efforts.”
The move towards stricter regulations and the emphasis on neutral expressions gained momentum with the advancement of biometric technology. Around 2004, both the U.S. and other countries updated their passport photo guidelines to better accommodate facial recognition systems. “The face has always been the standard for biometric identification by the International Civil Aviation Organization, but because computers are limited in specific facial recognition capabilities, a neutral expression was deemed the gold standard,” explains Nastro. This shift reflects the increasing reliance on technology to enhance security and the need for standardized facial images for effective biometric identification.
Risks of Smiling: What Happens If You Don’t Comply?
Submitting a passport photo with a broad smile, or any expression that deviates significantly from the neutral requirement, can lead to complications in your passport application process. “The most common reason for a passport processing delay is improper photos,” states Nastro. “Even the best of smiles can get turned down for not meeting requirements set forth on the state department website. It’s best to not risk it and take a photo with a neutral expression, especially if you want it processed as quickly as possible.”
If your passport photo is deemed unacceptable due to a smile or any other non-compliant aspect, the passport agency will delay your application. You will receive a notification, typically a letter or email, with instructions on how to resubmit a compliant photograph. This delay can be particularly problematic if you have urgent travel plans.
Blancaflor warns, “If you’re unable to provide a photo that meets their standards by the deadline given, your passport application may remain in ‘on hold’ limbo forever or be rejected.” Therefore, adhering to the photo guidelines, including the neutral expression requirement, is crucial to ensure a smooth and timely passport application process.
Special Considerations: Children and Medical Reasons
While the neutral expression rule is generally strict, there are some exceptions and more lenient interpretations for specific situations, particularly for children. Turowska notes, “The stringent rule regarding smiling is somewhat more lenient for children since having them maintain a neutral facial expression is challenging. The smile cannot impair the recognition of their facial features; however, as long as the child faces the camera and has his eyes open, the passport authorities should accept a smiling photo.” For infants and young children, the focus is more on capturing a clear image of their face with open eyes, rather than enforcing a perfectly neutral expression.
There are also provisions for medical and religious reasons that might affect photo requirements. For instance, eyeglasses are generally prohibited, but exceptions are made for medical reasons, requiring a signed doctor’s statement. Similarly, hats or head coverings are not allowed unless they are part of traditional religious attire worn continuously in public, which also necessitates a signed statement attesting to this.
Tips for a Compliant and Acceptable Passport Photo
To ensure your passport photo is accepted and avoids delays, follow these key tips:
- Maintain a Neutral Expression: Keep your face relaxed and avoid smiling broadly or showing your teeth. A slight, closed-mouth smile might be acceptable, but neutral is safest.
- Mouth Closed: Ensure your mouth is closed. Avoid open-mouth smiles, grinning, or any other open-mouth expressions.
- Eyes Open and Looking Straight: Keep both eyes open and look directly at the camera.
- Proper Lighting and Background: Use even lighting and a plain white or off-white background. Avoid shadows on your face or background.
- No Eyeglasses (Generally): Remove eyeglasses unless they cannot be removed for medical reasons, with supporting documentation.
- No Hats or Head Coverings (Unless Religious): Hats and head coverings are generally prohibited, except for religious attire with a signed statement.
- Avoid Exaggerated Expressions: In addition to smiling, avoid frowning, squinting, or raising your eyebrows excessively. As Turowska mentions, “Not only is smiling prohibited: Applicants cannot tighten their mouths, frown or crinkle.”
For complete and up-to-date guidelines, always refer to the official State Department website or the passport authority of your country.
Conclusion
While the idea of a serious, non-smiling passport photo might seem unappealing, understanding the reasons behind the “neutral expression” rule highlights its importance. It’s not about suppressing happiness, but about ensuring your photo meets international standards for biometric identification. By adhering to these guidelines, you contribute to a more secure and efficient travel process and avoid unnecessary delays in obtaining your passport. So, when it’s time for your passport photo, remember to relax, face the camera, and think “neutral” rather than “cheese.”
